1v1 Abbadon. Ghazkul has been defeated by a humie, a special humie but still a humie. Calgar is not in this league. Eldrad would not 1v1 and if it somehow happened he would likely have an advantage of some sort. Overall, I think Eldrad would win by either arranging the fight to have them rid the galaxy of one or more of the other three or would have an elaborate purpose or trap behind the fight that suits his purposes.
Not really, basically they're talking about his miniature figure, his arms weigh too much that they fall off his figure. Or something like that. I'm not too sure to be honest. :/
I'd go with Abaddon. The dude is resilient you have to grant him that. He's the only one to have brought the nine traitor legions and the four major chaos powers under a single banner not once, but thirteen times (and the crusades were arguably failures yet they kept assembling under his banner). He's pretty powerful in my book. He might get his bottom kicked around but in the end he'll prevail, he just refuses to concede defeat. He really needs a haircut though.
I wholeheartedly believe that chaos would make it out of the eye. That's not the point. The losses sustained would be massive. The orks wouldn't incur these losses. Hell, even if they ventured into the Eye to go after Abaddon, they still wouldn't have it as rough.
Its not as simple as who would win. Eldrad would know the fight had to happen. Abaddon would think he orchestrated the entire thing. Magneus would not see it coming as he'd be to distracted with Tigurius, eavesdropping on the Tyranid. Gork and Mork would tell Ghazghkull of "da best brawl eva." Eldrad would piss everyone off with his psychic tickles and then bow out early because really what can a twig do against three terminator sized monsters? Abaddon would quickly go from master manipulator to tunnel-vision berserker. Magneus would try and go all spartan on everyone but unfortunately the Codex Astartes didn't cover this. Ghazghkull would be having the time of his life. When the dust settles half a world will be in ruin. Three of the greatest threats to some Craftworld somewhere would be eliminated, because, you know, they'd do something to it. At some time in the distant future. Like litter.
I'm going to have to side with Gaz too...but if you added Sebastian Yarrick in there...well we all know who would win then.
Maybe I'm wrong but didn't Yarrick lost multiple times against Gaz? I don't think he will do it without a lot of support.
