You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means. How is Painboy asymmetrical? its an exact copy of the apoc just worse.Asymmetry would be painboy getting a unique powerklaw while the apoc stays how it is.
Melta bombs on Scorpions however would just end up making the fire dragons almost non essential. But I can see Krak like grenades on hawks if they want an alternative to Haywire.
This is a lot of word play but you need to expand on your point, what exactly about 1:1 comparison doesn't work? Team composition? It doesn't matter much, I saw a game today where someone playing exclusively apothecary got fifty kills, give that some power to self heal, bolter, rightclick strafe out of fire, and outperform a regular ranged marine to orks. That's all I advocated, I could try saying that the apoth needs to be nerfed down so it actually preforms as a support role instead of a direct combat unit like I saw today but that's not fair because I don't have the number crunches. So just copy paste it to ork doc and their counterparts. Easy fix.
When any of those things result in a game where a single ork player gets 50 kills we can talk about the same thing. But it doesn't matter, it's a logical fallacy to name one wrong to justify another. But I asked you a question about what's wrong with 1:1 comparison too mind you.
so i just have to get 50 kills as ork to get ork OP ? ez brb 1:1 comparisons are jsut plain stupid considering painboy is weak to compensate for the fact that the whole race is strong af Edit: plz dont use skill as an argument thanks