*is an Eldar*

*says melee is too difficult*

Didn't say it was TOO difficult, said Its hard vs power fists and klaw and wanted to get better at dueling than I already am! Which everyone should want to do I would think.

Master crafted is the first step to help you vs fists/klaws
Repair generator is another addition

Agreed, I changed my scorp sword to master crafted with clash engine and penetration, I have more success. I'm looking forward to the toughness/pen patch which will make all weapons higher pen thankfully.

My personal option, (but i don't play Scorpion) ,if i was limited to power sword, would be repair generator, to get the weapon to regen durability, Master crafted. And simple dmg bonus, or power attack dmg.

But this would be, specifically to prevent vs fists.
And if it can beat fists, it probably will do well vs the rest

EDIT:

Nevermind, i forgot scorps have chainswords even though they hit like trains...and therefore don't have repair generators.
So yeah, master crafted, impact and pen like you've said, Although i'm more adept of straight dmg.

Valid choices though I wonder whether you're not putting too much towards dealing with the PF. Remember that PF is also the slowest of the melee weapons. You're playing Eldar. A core principal of the race is that you don't go into head-to-head clashes with a stronger foe and choose your fights. A PF doesn't deal well with getting shot at after swinging and a chainsword quite handily beats it when it's being introduced to the PF user through the backdoor

I have, I was trying to combine it with the dread gazebo skit where a player comes upon a gazebo but doesn't know what a gazebo is so he thinks it is an enemy. It is hilarious.

Now I gotta watch it.

That's why I like my scorpion over my banshee. If I do see a power fist I can just hide until it walks by, and go on my merry way. Or if I fee confident I can back attack them.

One thing I've noticed is power attacking s moving target as they pass you almost never hits. Gotta stop doing that. I've also noticed how vast majority of people just spam light attack. It beats heavy, clashe slight, so you're only gonna be beaten by DBash, and even then you can roll out of it. What I do now after all your help is I DBash and roll forward into the enemy. I'm behind them and they usually can't roll to anywhere that will save them!

Versus a fist, you can try and Dbash, and then he will roll back.If you roll back too, you've increased your distance, and can shoot him down. he won't make a power attack, because it can't cover two rolls. So he'll try fast attack, and then you can dbash again.

Just a theory, but try it out