Sorry but i'm not going to give a game a positive rose tinted glasses review if it doesn't deserve it, and being dishonest about the games current state does not help, being honest about the problem players experience helps developers focus on critical areas that need to be improved upon. And yes i think EC has the potential to be something great, its never gonna be planetside 2 wh40k style, forget that now, but it can be a really good instanced arena battle shooter. But everything i said about EC was valid, you can't accept the criticism of EC, i can only hope the Developers have a different outlook from you.
Listen, contrary to what many of you might think I am quite happy to sit here and list all of ECs faults. I just don't think what you said was necessarily fair in all aspects and is very opinionated. You said the melee was a clusterfuck, I'd say it was close to being perfect. You said the maps were bf40kmod worthy and I think they are actually pretty well designed in the main. The vehicles I agree are awful to control. Optimisation is poor at the minute but they are working on it and it's not bad on every machine. Criticism is definitely valid and useful but it's much more useful if it's constructive rather than just scathing. Like say which maps you hate and why, say why you don't like the melee system or why you think it's broken.
The maps are horrible, look at all the amazing gothic architecture in wh40k artwork, there's none of that, what about architecture of other race's? none of that either. Melee is a clusterf**k, especially when spamming fast attack merits more rewards than it does utilizing the r/p/s system, seeing some dude just spamming fast attack at you and D-bashing him results in YOU being stunned, or catching someone from behind twice with a heavy attack having no effect, only for them to turn around swing once and you die, maybe there's elements of melee i'm not aware of, and if there is its certainly not documented anywhere. I think latency issues doesn't help melee, its a shame because it should be fun and the animations look great, but ultimately its an exercise in frustration.
Omg this game has a worse rating than No Man's Sky on top games list...atm place 125 for EC and 115 for NMS (i know thats not a comparison worthy of anything, but just struck me as interesting). Subnautica that is a nowhere near finished early access game is on place 93...incidentally its quite promising, but then again we know how that goes, go check it out (no im not affiliated more then just a backer ^^).
